
Ask anyone why this John Landis comedy werewolf horror is rated so highly and you will meet with a flurry or reasons, and probably some scorn for daring to query the quality too. The effects are amazing!, they will cry. It’s so funny!, they will shout. It’s the best werewolf movie of all time!, they will claim. So what? We whisper.
The special effects are, of course, extremely good. Given the limitations of both the movie’s budget and the year the film was made, the transformation scene that sits so firmly in the hearts and minds of genre fans still impress. But it doesn’t convince. It’s a stellar technical achievement but that’s different to an effect that doesn’t impede on the suspension of disbelief. Of course, you can’t criticize the creators for such marvelous work, but you can certainly disagree with those who maintain that this is still most convincing werewolf transformation ever.
The humor, too, hasn’t aged brilliantly, but unlike the effects this aspects was never state of the art anyway. The parodic, B movie tone the tale of the transforming tourist strikes was never particularly smart or new. Indeed it genuinely doesn’t offer much more than an episode of The Simpsons TreeHouse of Horror, and this isn’t helped by some rather stupid skits and limited performances.
